Cannell Capital Files Schedule 13D for Build-A-Bear Workshop Suggesting the Company Tender for Its Own Shares
Alta, Wyoming--(Newsfile Corp. - August 31, 2022) - Cannell Capital LLC published a letter to the Board of Directors of Build-A-Bear Workshop, Inc. (NASDAQ: BBW) in a Schedule 13-D filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission on August 25, 2022. This filing and the letter can be reviewed online here. The letter appears in its entirety below.
August 25, 2022
Board of Directors
Build-A-Bear Workshop, Inc.
415 South 18th Street
Saint Louis, MO 63103
Cannell Capital LLC ("CC"), the largest shareholder of Build-A-Bear Workshop, Inc. ("BBW" or the "Company") as of June 30, 2022, believes that BBW enjoys an ahistorical opportunity to add value for owners through a tender of its own stock and on July 21 demanded such.
On July 22, BBW requested a reasonable amount of time to ruminate upon this demand. CC has waited 34 days. Now CC makes its position public since BBW has taken no action.
To view an enhanced version of Fig. 1, please visit:
Please consider the following as part of this request.
The Company enjoys excess liquidity - $26 million of cash and no debt as of March 31, 2022 - and borrowing capacity of up to $25 million at about 5% interest (CC estimates). This arguable overcapitalization is increasing as BBW generated $20 million of free cash flow last year and CC expects our Company to generate at least $30 million more this year. Furthermore, BBW owns a 350,000 square-foot distribution center in Ohio that, if monetized via a sale leaseback transaction, would yield about $35 million.
BBW management may know how to manage stores, but the Board of Directors to whom management is supposed to report has done a poor job allocating owners' capital. See Figure 1.
The experience of CC is that when owners have little skin in the game - real skin which they buy and are not given - capital allocation resonates less. Officers and directors have bought little to no shares of BBW.
BBW is significantly under-leveraged relative to its mall-based specialty retailer peers. Bath & Body Works, Inc. (BBWI), for instance, carries net debt equal to 2x trailing twelve-month EBITDA.
Using sell-side consensus estimates, BBW's stock is trading at just 6x 2022 estimated EPS, its lowest level in about 18 years.
By our math, if BBW were to monetize its real estate assets and take net leverage to just 1x through a tender at $17 per share, 2022 earnings per share would grow 110% inclusive of incremental interest and leasing costs.
Fig. 2. BBW Buyback Calculus
($ million, FY Jan)
|Net Leverage Target||0x||0.5x||1.0x|
|Cash on hand FQ1 2022||$26||$26||$26|
|Estimated proceeds from sale leaseback||35||35||35|
|Shares repurchased (million)||5.1||7.3||9.4|
|% Total S/O repurchased||33%||47%||60%|
|Assumed Cost of Debt||5.5%||6.5%||8.0%|
|CY consensus net income estimate||43||43||43|
|Assumed incremental lease expense||(2)||(2)||(2)|
|PF net income||$40||$39||$36|
|PF Adjusted EPS||$3.92||$4.70||$5.85|
|% Boost to Consensus EPS||41%||69%||110%|
|Earnings Yield %||25%||30%||38%|
CC grows weary of BBW's poor capital allocation. As illustrated in Figure 1, CC has repeatedly advocated for buybacks only to see the lethargic Board buy back shares at prices 255% to 274% higher than when its largest owner advocated.
On July 21 CC talked to BBW and urged its Board of Directors to conduct a modified Dutch tender for BBW's common stock. CC agreed to give BBW more time in which to arrange the legal and compliance groundwork for such an offer. BBW management's inaction has left CC with no option but to release this letter and with it our decisive vote of "no confidence" in the Board. All owners of BBW should consider whether new directors wouldn't be better stewards of our Company.
J. Carlo Cannell
Stephen C. Wagstaff
To view the source version of this press release, please visit https://www.newsfilecorp.com/release/135552