MIP99: Offer DAI to CeFi projects to enable real-world use cases

MIP99: Offer DAI to CeFi Projects to Enable Real-world Use Cases

Preamble

MIP#: 99
Title: Offer DAI to CeFi projects to enable real-world use cases
Author(s): @FluidFinance
Contributors:
Tags: mips
Type: General
Status: Obsolete
Date Proposed: 2023-01-19
Date Ratified: <yyyy-mm-dd>
Forum URL: https://forum.makerdao.com/t/mip99-offer-dai-to-cefi-projects-to-enable-real-world-use-cases/19466
Extra: This proposal has been made obsolete by the passage of MIP102c2-SP1.

References

Sentence Summary

The MIP would enable Maker to sell Dai to anyone, globally, and capture the revenue from these sales. Revenues could be paid to the Maker treasury or streamed to MKR holders.

Paragraph Summary

At the moment, to buy Dai, users need to purchase a separate product (ETH, USDC, etc) from separate companies. This often involves transferring money through the traditional financial system to a centralized exchange. It is an inefficient, expensive process that requires the user to have an exchange account, undertake often extensive KYC, and be able to use a Web3 wallet. By definition, it limits users to a small percentage of the population who have expert knowledge.

Fluid and Maker should work together for a simple implementation of buy (and sell) buttons via the Maker website. This would allow users to buy and sell Dai directly from their bank account (or Fluid Account) with Fluid, and encourage greater adoption of Dai.

Component Summary

The rise of DeFi in 2020 is positively correlated with the growth in dollar denominated stablecoins assets. We see Dai as being at the heart of a healthy DeFi economy.

The problems in DeFi include: centralized exchanges, centralized stablecoins, lack of real-world utility and potential regulatory attack. The combination of Dai and Fluid solves these problems and lays the foundation for mass adoption of DeFi.

Dai is essentially open-source software providing a decentralized, digital version of currency. It has significant value because

• Dai has the same denomination as real-world liabilities (i.e. dollar denominated). 
• Dai is user-owned. 

The market for dollars outside the US, for trade, wealth-preservation, etc. is enormous. Banks’ outstanding cross-border dollar deposits (outside the US) at the end of 2021 were $15.4 trillion and dollar-denominated global trade was $22.8 trillion, 13% higher than the pre-Covid level. This is Dai’s total addressable market.

Tangibly, you can send Dai around the world almost instantly and almost for free. There is enormous demand for dollars, and Dai is technically superior to traditional currency alternatives.

The main problem is that the benefits of Dai are not easily available in the real economy.

Fluid enables seamless integration of Dai into the real economy. Together, Dai and Fluid put the user in control and deliver tangible, real-world benefits that are superior to TradFi alternatives.

Here is what the solution looks like:

Fluid allows users to mint their own digital cash, which is a digital version of money held in their account. It is essentially real money, on-chain. And, it is available in 32 different currencies.

You can drag and drop real money from your account to your Web3 wallet.

Then, you can swap your digital dollars for Dai directly on our fluidswap.

The benefits of Dai + Fluid’s digital cash, DUSD, are set out below.

We have been testing our Stable Pool on Balancer (on Arbitrum) for several months now. You can see it here: Balancer. We are planning to launch on Ethereum mainnet soon. Of course, the development of Maker Teleport helps making currency movements nearly instant across these chains.

Fluid enables Dai holders to offramp from crypto to a bank account (or Fluid Account) in less than a minute.
Holders can also spend their Dai on their Fluid Cards, which run on the Mastercard network. These cards are available to anyone, globally.
You can see these on YouTube here: - YouTube.

Fluid also allows crypto degens the easiest way to buy assets in the real world, as you can see from the testimonial here : Avis sur Fluid Finance SA Ă©crit par B M le 6/6/2022.

By seamlessly linking Dai to the traditional financial system, we hope that this will encourage greater use of Dai and the broader crypto ecosystem.

Motivation

This MIP has three main objectives.

1. Generate revenues for Maker and MKR holders. 
2. Encourage mass adoption of Dai (and crypto). 
3. Allow users to by-pass centralized exchanges. 

Specification / Proposal Details

The MIP would permit the integration of a link to Fluid Finance for users who want to buy or sell Dai directly from their bank account (or Fluid Account). Fees would be shared equally with Maker, giving the protocol an attractive new revenue stream and encouraging adoption of Dai.

Using an estimate that about 5% of TVL could on/off ramp via Maker + Fluid directly, this would bring in revenues of $51.3 million over the next 12 months. Anyone globally could buy Dai directly, using bank transfers, cards or open banking.

We think that these estimates, based only on existing crypto flows, are extremely conservative, as they don’t take into consideration target markets of cross-border dollar flows, including trade finance, remittances, creator economy payments, etc. for which Dai should be the main currency. Expanding Dai to these markets would increase revenues to Maker and MKR holders by over 1,000x.

You can see the working financial model, below. You can also edit it for different assumptions.

Extremely conservative, crypto-only, no growth, no new markets case:

We intend to make another Maker Improvement Proposal to add the digital version of our currencies shortly.
We currently offer a digital version of the US dollar, available in our Dai - DUSD pool on Balancer on Arbitrum. We refer to this as real money, on-chain, rather than a stablecoin since it is just a digital representation of US dollars deposited with our banking partners.

There is a direct claim to deposited funds, of course, and we expect that these can be accessed via a smart contract under the control of Maker, using API.
There is no (minimal) time delay in accessing funds and they would be completely under the control of Maker. Of course, like any real-world asset, they are subject to legal and regulatory action.

35 Likes

This post has been reserved for GovAlpha’s proposal summary on proposal MIP99: Offer DAI to CeFi projects to enable real-world use cases

1 Like

I have difficulties to understand what exactly the outcome of this proposal will be. Please could you summarize the action that would result?

2 Likes

Very interesting proposal. Can you provide some links where I could see how DUSD collateral is managed and reported? What is the redemption process like?

There are a suspicious number of likes on this post from new forum accounts.

Of 26 “likes”, 25 are from accounts registered in the last five hours.

I do hope this isn’t an attempt by the applicant to influence the Governance process by spoofing social approval for this proposal.

I would encourage anyone reviewing this proposal to take the number of likes with a pinch of salt

7 Likes

Hello @rspa
You can find more information about DUSD on our website : Digital cash - Fluid Finance SA and the off-chain treasury API : https://retail.fluidfi.ch/gw/open/v1/treasury/DUSD .

As for the redemption / redeem you can exchange DAI against DUSD via the fluidswap on Arbitrum (Fluid Finance , we are also going to deploy the redeem on eth mainnet) or on the Arbitrum Balancer pool : Balancer

Once you have DUSD you can “redeem” it. No matter what price is on chain, 1 DUSD == 1$ (as it’s 1:1 backed. People are basically their own mint) on fluid : Fluid Finance

You can do all these steps with your own Web3 wallet, connected to the Fluid Interface. Once it’s redeemed you can use it to purchase real world assets.

3 Likes

Thanks, I’m looking for reports on what kind of assets are collateral for DUSD, ideally by an external auditor

1 Like

Thanks for your post but to clarify, there are many alternatives such as Moonpay. And there are various ways to pay with Dai such as WireX and I believe Crypto.com is still active with Dai. So how is it better than alternatives?

I usually don’t go this harsh but this is basically gaslighting the Maker community. Considering despite such options already exist, majority of crypto purchases using fiat goes via exchanges or OTC desks. And many including fiat on off ramps are forced to layoff or even shutdown as revenue is insufficient. Therefore, trying to frame it as a silver bullet is beyond misleading.

3 Likes

Is this supposed to be like a hyperlink on the Maker website that directs the user to Fluid’s website in order to purchase DAI from your fiat bank account?

DUSD and other digital currencies are just digital representations of what is in a bank account. Real money, on-chain. Not pegged to assets supposedly worth a dollar. No investments in treasury bonds, commercial paper, cash etc. unlike all of the others. Just an official bank statement every day. No need for audit, because no other assets that need to be counted, valued, etc.

1 Like

I guess it could be some people from our community since this thread has been shared in our community chat. If this is the case, sorry for that.

it can be any kind of “whitelabeling” - either Fluid can integrate Maker into their app, or Maker can show a kind of widget to connect and use the Fluid infrastructure to on-ramp/off-ramp. And our proposal is to do both.

Leaving aside the factual accuracy of this proposal (perhaps @strat-fin-core-unit could give their assessment of the 1,000x revenue claim…), there are some formatting issues with this proposal.

In order to be a valid MIP eligible to enter the Governance Cycle it must adhere to the MIP Template.

As the name suggests, this should be a summary of the components of the MIP, not a detailed description. Much of what has been posted here should be moved to the Motivation section.

Proposal details should be separated into Components that are summarised in the Component Summary. e.g. MIP99c1 etc. See MIP0 as an example.

Neither the incorrectly formatted Component Summary nor the Specification actually clarifies what is being proposed here. From the Paragraph Summary it seems to be:

The specific goal and implementation plan of the MIP should be clearly stated in the Specification.

If these issues aren’t resolved, this MIP will not be eligible to proceed to a vote. Please liaise with @MIP-Editors if you have further questions.

5 Likes

Still not clear what is it that this proposal will actually do. You can integrate dai in your app already i dont think you need a mip for that

We just saw your tweet @FluidFinance and wanted to let you know that we had no idea what this proposal was about, but it became clearer in 10 seconds of reading the bitcoin.com article:

Jessica Walker at Fluid said: “One of the problems with crypto is the lack of connection to the real world. Fluid solves that by integrating Dai directly into our accounts. Users can buy Dai directly from us using dollars, euros, pounds and dozens of other currencies. Dai holders can also now buy coffee on their Fluid Cards, which operate on the Mastercard network”.

Fluid offers traditional bank accounts in Europe and the UK and Fluid Accounts, which are open to anyone globally. Users can connect their Web3 wallets to these accounts, for a seamless TradFi – DeFi experience. “Gone are the days of having to go through an exchange,” – said Walker.

MakerDAO is at a point of major transition and restructuring, so there may soon be a few different paths available for you to advance this proposal. In the meantime we wanted to share the feedback that the above paragraphs from the article caught our attention as interesting. However, the title of this MIP and what was posted here communicated none of this information in our initial quick review - maybe we missed it.

We’d suggest having a team member of yours spend some time with the community at public calls and following conversation in the Discord to assist in retooling your approach. Others will continue to give feedback if you respond to the comments here on this thread.

Thank you for the proposal!

2 Likes

That would be great for further adoption of DAI and the recent Bakery Finance/Real World Assets development make this partnership that much better.

1 Like

While we are curious how some Maker community members are getting swayed by a token project with remarkable $5,000 trading volume as somehow a potential partner to increase revenue by 1000x (so will be in billions in revenue?), we strongly advice the community to examine proposals by this protocol more carefully.

2 Likes

Thank you everyone for your honest feedback. After some deliberation we have decided to suspend our MIP in order to reformat according to the MIP template standards and to modify some points for clarity.

As mentioned before, our goal is to provide tangible back-and-forth access between the crypto universe and the physical world. We believe that Maker is the obvious path to achieve this goal, so expect to hear from us soon!

Thank you all.

3 Likes

CC: @MIP-Editors

1 Like

This topic was automatically closed 90 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.